Is Acrylic More Damaging Than Gel? A Professional Analysis

Are acrylic nails more damaging than gel nails? This article leverages expert insights to inform press-on nail professionals and salon owners about acrylic vs. gel damage, application safety, and best use practices. Understand key differences with clear, actionable facts.

Key Differences: Acrylic vs. Gel

- Acrylic Nails:

- Created by mixing liquid monomer with powder polymer.

- Dries and hardens via air exposure.

- Typically thicker and more rigid.

- Requires buffing of the natural nail during application.

- Usually removed by soaking in acetone.

- Gel Nails:

- Composed of methacrylate compounds, pre-mixed and ready to use.

- Cures under a UV or LED lamp.

- Known for a glossy finish and flexibility.

- Minimal filing of the natural nail is required.

- Easily soaked off with acetone or gel remover.

Potential for Damage

Acrylic: Greater Potential for Natural Nail Damage

- Heavy buffing and priming can thin and weaken nails ((https://www.probeauty.org)).

- Acrylic’s rigid structure can cause natural nail flex and splitting.

- Removal often requires prolonged acetone exposure.

- Incomplete removal or forced lifting can strip natural nail layers.

Gel: Less Aggressive but Not Without Risks

- Gentler on the nail during application; less filing needed.

- Softer gel materials may reduce risk of trauma ((https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)).

- Quick curing process and flexibility lead to fewer cracks.

- Incorrect removal (peeling or scraping) can still damage the nail plate.

Industry Best Practices for Minimizing Damage

- Proper Application:

- Avoid excessive filing or buffing on the natural nail, especially with acrylic systems.

- Use quality primers and bonders to reduce the need for mechanical abrasion.

- Safe Removal:

- Always soak nails sufficiently in acetone for both acrylic and gel types.

- Never force material off; use gentle scraping and keep nails moisturized.

- Professional wrap techniques help limit acetone contact with the skin.

- Professional Training:

- Regularly update application/removal skills to adhere to latest safety standards.

- Educate clients on at-home care and appropriate removal intervals.

Data-Driven Insights

- A 2023 PBA (Professional Beauty Association) survey showed 68% of nail techs report more frequent surface damage after acrylic use than gel.

- Studies confirm improper removal, not the product itself, accounts for most long-term damage.

Press-On Nails: A Gentler Alternative

- Press-ons sidestep the aggressive filing and soaking associated with both acrylic and gel.

- Reusable and removable with simple, non-damaging adhesives.

- Ideal for professionals who prioritize client nail health.

Conclusion: Understanding Client Needs

Acrylic can be more damaging than gel, primarily due to harsher application and removal processes. However, both require skilled technique. Press-on nails present a safer, versatile option for professionals and clients alike.

For the latest in nail products, safety techniques, and press-on solutions, visit Xianxing Beauty—your trusted partner in nail innovation.