Are Press-On Nails Healthier Than Acrylic?

Press-on nails and acrylic nails are popular choices for achieving long, beautiful nails, but which is healthier for your natural nails? This article compares the two, providing insights for nail professionals.

Damage Potential: Press-On vs. Acrylic

Press-on nails: Generally less damaging. Proper application and removal are key. Improper removal can lead to lifting, peeling, and damage to the natural nail plate. The adhesive used can also sometimes cause irritation in sensitive individuals.

Acrylic nails: Carry a higher risk of damage. The application process involves filing and buffing the natural nail, making it thinner and potentially more prone to breakage and infection. Improper removal by filing or prying can seriously damage the nail bed. Furthermore, the chemicals used in acrylic application (monomer and polymer) can cause allergic reactions or irritation in some clients.

Nail Health Considerations

Press-on nails: Offer a temporary enhancement, minimizing prolonged exposure to harsh chemicals. The risk of damage is significantly reduced if applied and removed correctly, following the manufacturer’s instructions and using a gentle removal method.

Acrylic nails: Require ongoing maintenance, increasing exposure to chemicals and the risk of damage with each refill. The constant filing and buffing weakens the natural nail over time. Poor salon hygiene practices can increase the risk of infection.

Long-Term Effects

Press-on nails: With proper care, press-on nails allow for breaks between applications, giving the natural nails time to recover and regain strength.

Acrylic nails: Can lead to thinning, weakening, and brittleness of the natural nails if applied frequently or improperly. This can result in long-term damage requiring extensive nail rehabilitation.

Conclusion

While both methods offer aesthetic benefits, press-on nails generally pose a lower risk to natural nail health when applied and removed correctly. However, educating clients on proper application and removal techniques for both press-on and acrylic nails is crucial for maintaining nail health.